Black Friday used to be more predictable: one day, one massive rush, and some incredible deals that shoppers would happily stand in the cold for. Today, the holiday shopping landscape looks nothing like it did a decade ago. The event has stretched from a single day to a season-long campaign; online shopping has replaced long lines, and perhaps the biggest shift of all — customers are getting wise to how the sales game is played.
Retailers who want to win today can’t rely on hype or “too good to be true” promotions. Shoppers have seen behind the curtain, and trust has become one of the most valuable currencies a retailer can hold.
Black Friday no longer begins on Friday. Some retailers launch deals the first week of November. Others drip out “early access” promotions, then weekend deals, then Cyber Monday follow-ups.
What used to be a one-day event is now a four-week runway (or longer!). Instead of a single surge of traffic, retailers see waves — across channels and in-store, and increasingly driven by loyalty programs and email-exclusive offers.
This new pattern has forced retailers to think less about a sprint and more about a season: keeping momentum, spreading out promotions, and maintaining a consistent customer experience across channels.
One of the biggest developments shaping the modern holiday season is this: customers no longer take a “sale” at face value.
A recent six-month pricing study by Consumers’ Checkbook followed major national retailers and found that many “sale” prices aren’t special at all — often the items are sold at those supposed discounts nearly every week of the year.
In other words, the markdowns aren’t really markdowns. And shoppers are catching on.
They’ve learned to compare prices, use tracking tools, and wait for alerts. Modern technology has made it easier than ever to monitor pricing. Many assume that a crossed-out “regular price” was never the real price at all.
This erosion of trust doesn’t just shape how customers shop on Black Friday — it shapes how they shop all the time. People are tired of the pressure tactics, the urgency language, and the “90% off!” claims that don’t feel real.
Consumers are jaded. And this creates an opportunity for retailers who want to stand out.
Customers reward the brands that play it straight. When shoppers believe a retailer is honest about pricing, they don’t feel the need to open 17 tabs to compare. They spend more confidently. They become repeat buyers. And during a competitive season like Black Friday, that trust can be a major differentiator.
Retailers can build it in simple ways:
Shoppers want value, not manipulation. And when retailers give it to them, both sides win.
The shift toward digital shopping accelerated the trust conversation. Online, customers can compare in seconds. They can check price history. They can see reviews and alternatives right away.
And the shift isn’t slowing down. Whether browsing on mobile, checking out on desktop, or picking up curbside, today’s shopper expects an experience that feels seamless across every touchpoint.
Retailers have responded by refining workflows, tightening up shipping policies, and improving the in-store experience so it’s worth the visit.
Above: Black Friday isn’t just about fighting the crowds anymore. Stores are still busy, but shoppers now hunt for deals across every channel.
Shoppers used to fear missing out on a once-a-year deal. Now they fear overspending. And for good reason: interest charges, junk fees, and impulse buying can turn a “great deal” into something much more expensive.
This year, studies show shoppers are planning more carefully, budgeting earlier, and taking extra time before checking out — sometimes even intentionally leaving items in their cart for 24 hours to cool off.
Retailers who acknowledge this shift instead of fighting it — those who help customers make smart decisions instead of pressured ones — tend to earn repeat business long after the holidays.
Black Friday has transformed. And it’s not going back. The brands thriving in this new era share a few characteristics:
The future of Black Friday belongs to retailers who recognize that customers aren’t easily impressed by splashy percent-offs anymore. They’re impressed by brands that respect them.
Give shoppers honest pricing, meaningful loyalty rewards, and a smooth, unified shopping experience — and they’ll reward you long after the holiday season ends.
Want more retail insights like these? Subscribe to our FieldNotes blog 👇